Cruising the Mekong River

Quick Take: Finding Balance on the Mekong River

Jeff Opperman, The Nature Conservancy|August 31, 2016|Blog Post

This blog originally appeared on Cool Green Science, the science blog of The Nature Conservancy. 

A recent article by the Economist offers a richly complex review of the conflicts roiling the waters of the Mekong River in Southeast Asia. The magazine’s nuanced synthesis is summarized by a non-subtle plea on its cover: “don’t dam the Mekong.”

Several dozen hydropower dams are under construction or planned in the basin, including 11 for the main-stem of the river, threatening the largest and most important freshwater fish harvest in the world. The Mekong fishery produces more than 2 million tons per year, nearly 20 percent of theglobal total for freshwater fish harvest, and provides the primary source of protein and livelihood for tens of millions of low income, rural people in Laos, Cambodia and Vietnam.

Specifically, the editorial and essay in the Economist support a moratorium on dam construction on the main-stem of the Mekong, proposed in a 2010 report by the Mekong River Commission. The moratorium hasn’t changed the rapid pace of dam development, however. China has built six large dams on the upper river, and two-main stem dams are now under construction in Laos in the Mekong’s productive heart — the so-called Lower Mekong Basin. This area is characterized by productive floodplains, networks of channels that serve as a highway for migratory fish and huge populations that depend on this bounty of fish.

The Economist notes that “the biggest problem with the dam-building schemes is their lack of co-ordination.” This lack of coordination is no doubt exacerbated by the fact that Mekong flows through six countries. However, hydropower development around the world is characterized by a lack of coordination, and this deficiency represents a huge lost opportunity to chart a course toward a future with sustainable energy and healthy rivers.

The Nature Conservancy recently released a report, The Power of Rivers, which showed that coordinated planning, as advocated by the Economist, could result in better outcomes for 100,000 kilometers of rivers worldwide during the next few decades of hydropower expansion. This research suggests that coordinated planning that strives to balance a range of river values could help manage the projected hydropower boom in a way that leaves the world with far more free-flowing rivers, productive fisheries and healthy communities than will result from status quo development.

A recent study by researcher Guy Ziv and colleagues provides a specific demonstration for the Mekong: among nearly 30 potential dams on Mekong tributaries, careful selection of which dams are built and which are not built could lead to a system that provides 75 percent of all the available energy from tributary dams, while only diminishing basin-wide migratory fish populations by 3 percent. However, building just a few of the most damaging projects — those with the biggest impact on fish migration — could cut migratory basin-wide fish populations by nearly 20 percent. That’s nearly a seven-fold increase in impacts for a system of dams with similar, or potentially even less, energy levels (note that main-stem dams would have greater impacts than tributary dams).

The world is currently looking to maximize most forms of energy — particularly those with a small carbon footprint. Hydropower will no doubt contribute a major part to the world’s energy mix in the coming decades. But we shouldn’t solve the climate crisis on the backs of unique and productive rivers around the world. There is a better way, and governments, companies, civil society and communities need to work together to find solutions to get this right. Too much is at stake, in the Mekong and other rivers around the world, to get it wrong.

Related Blog Posts

  • Mountain Gorilla, Rwanda
    Blog Post

    The 10 Best Places to See Animals in the Wild

    October 4, 2017 | Blog Post

    I’ve been a nature-lover my whole life, but I began traveling specifically to see animals in the wild back in the early ’90s. Still in my early 20s then, I was fascinated by watching wildlife. My passion grew exponentially as I took up photography and became more adept at spotting hidden animals.

    Read More

    Chaba Camp, India
    Blog Post

    Haute in the Himalayas

    September 12, 2017 | Blog Post

    A semi-autonomous region in north India, Ladakh earned the moniker “land of high passes” for its strategic location along ancient Himalayan trade routes. It is also known as the “land of the lamas” for the vast number of monuments and monasteries nestled throughout the Buddhist ex-kingdom.

    Read More

    The Himalayas
    Blog Post

    Altitude Sickness Remedies & Prevention

    August 14, 2017 | Blog Post

    It was a dream come true: I was in Bhutan, hiking up a steep incline to one of the world’s most coveted destinations.

    Read More

  • Borneo beach
    Blog Post

    Multi-Dimensional Borneo

    August 4, 2017 | Blog Post

    Like a bowl of its popular Sarawak laksa soup, Borneo is a complex concoction that is rich with flavor and rapidly addictive. The third-largest island in the world behind Greenland and New Guinea, Borneo spans some 287,000 square miles—more than Texas and twice the size of Germany.

    Read More

    Sepilok Orangutan Rehabilitation Center
    Blog Post

    Orangutans: The Wild Gingers of Borneo

    July 17, 2017 | Blog Post

    Redheads have a reputation for being deeply sensitive and extremely loyal. They sport the rarest hair color in the world—which, by the way, never turns gray, but rather straight to white.

    Read More

    The Koran, Iran
    Blog Post

    The Iran Travel Warning: Separating Fact from Fiction

    June 28, 2017 | Blog Post

    For many people, Iran is a country commonly associated with violent war and religious extremism. Named one of the countries in the “Axis of Evil” by President George W. Bush, Iran has almost always been covered in a negative light by the international media.

    Read More

  • Dharamsala, India
    Blog Post

    Dharamsala, India: A Guide for Nature Lovers & Spiritual Seekers

    June 22, 2017 | Blog Post

    In March of 1959, a young, bespectacled Buddhist monk born under the name Lhamo Thondup secretly escaped from his home among the snowcapped Himalayas. Leaving “the rooftop of the world,” he disguised himself as a soldier and, along with a retinue of supporters, traveled through the rugged mountain terrain towards freedom and safety.

    Read More

    Blog Post

    Iran Travel Guide: The Top 10 Places to Visit

    June 13, 2017 | Blog Post

    Traveling to Iran means immersing yourself in a millenary culture, appreciating some of the finest Islamic architecture on the planet, tasting delicious food, and enjoying heartfelt hospitality.

    Read More

    Lake Toya, Japan
    Blog Post

    Fireworks Over Lake Toya

    June 7, 2017 | Blog Post

    Each evening between May and October, colorful pyrotechnics illuminate the skies over Lake Toya, as hundreds of fireworks are set off from boats on the still waters. The spectacular event attracts hundreds of thousands of visitors annually to the scenic lake, which lends its name to the surrounding Shikotsu-Toya National Park on Japan’s northernmost main island, Hokkaido.

    Read More

  • Miyajima Island, Japan
    Blog Post

    The Best Japanese Islands to Explore

    June 6, 2017 | Blog Post

    Japan is a timeless travel destination, blending ancient cultural traditions with a love of forward-thinking technology. You would be forgiven for thinking that the nation is one big landmass, but it’s actually a volcanic archipelago made up of 6,852 Japanese islands. Of these, only 420 are inhabited.

    Read More

    Hokkaido: Japan's Wild Island
    Blog Post

    A Nature Lover's Guide to Hokkaido, Japan

    June 5, 2017 | Blog Post

    In the land of major metropolises and futuristic technology, there is still an oasis of calm and nature. Away from overcrowded subways, robot waiters, and neon intersections, Japan’s island of Hokkaido offers respite from the hustle and bustle of the cities.

    Read More

    Esfahan, Iran
    Blog Post

    How to Prepare for Travel to Iran: 9 Things You Need to Know

    May 31, 2017 | Blog Post

    Travel to Iran is unlike anything you’ve ever experienced. The country will blow you away with its natural beauty, millenary historical heritage, and especially the friendliness of its locals. The Persian people will lavish you with smiles and warm welcomes from the moment you step off the plane in Tehran.

    Read More